This weekend I theoretically took a brief "break" from chocolate dessert hunting to go pumpkin dessert hunting. In practice, of course, this means that I was going both pumpkin and chocolate dessert hunting, because bakeries typically have both, and I am not a strong man.
Tribeca Treats is a great shop. It's not too big, but you feel like you have plenty of space to stretch out -- a great place to sit around and hang out. They have bon bons, cupcakes, brownies, whoopie pies, and more. After putting in my pumpkin order (cheesecake and whoopie pie), I made my typical move -- ask for the chocolatiest thing they have. I wound up with a mini brownie and a dark chocolate bon bon covered in milk chocolate. Both were good, but very sweet. The non-obsessives in my group were particularly impressed with the brownie. It did indeed have an excellent fudgey texture. But I, of course, thought both could've been more chocolatey.
Bottom Line: A great place for a serious pumpkin lover and a casual chocolate appreciator.